TOWN councillors have recommended plans to build an extension at Lyme Regis Museum are rejected.

Members of Lyme Regis Town Council's planning and highways committee failed to back the proposals for the Mary Anning Wing - but gave their backing for listed building consent.

Councillors cited the appearance of the seaward facing extension, made from glass, zinc and aluminium as being out of keeping with the town.

Cllr Cheryl Reynolds, said: "I have nothing against the museum having an extension - but it is completely out of keeping with the area.

"I really don't like it at all. It's like a carbuncle - a blot on the landscape."

But some members spoke out in support of the plans.

Cllr Steve Miller said: "I see this as a very ambitious project. 

"I think the use of modern materials at the back of the museum enhances it.

"It will add enormous value to the museum. I think it will be a great development of Lyme Regis if it goes ahead."

Deputy mayor, Cllr Michaela Ellis added her support to the proposals, while Cllr John Broom said the developers should be 'congratulated' for their design.

Cllr Ellis said: "I think whenever a listed officer is looking at a building, they always like to see something completely different put on there and not to try to replicate what's already there.

"I think this will look much better."

But concerns were raised by Cllr Brian Larcombe about the amount of block zinc used for the extension, and suggested the plans could be 'more sympathetic' to the surroundings.

Speaking on behalf of the museum, trustee John Dover told councillors about the benefits the Mary Anning Wing would bring.

Mr Dover explained that West Dorset District Council has asked for a modern extension.

"Our development will make a serious contribution to the Lyme economy and help generate trade, " said Mr Dover. 

"It will help guarantee jobs. Our building will make a great contribution to Lyme's varied and lively seafront, just as the Guildhall was new and different in the 1880s and the museum in 1902.

"It will enable us to do much more with Lyme's schools and community groups. It will guarantee the sustainability of one of Lyme's oldest charities as local government funding declines.

"It will mean that we no longer have to send visitors and children across the road to use the public loos and offer disabled people the opportunity to see our first floor."

Councillors' recommendation that the proposals should not be approved, but that listed building consent should be granted will be handed over to West Dorset District Council.

Residents have until Saturday, August 15 to comment on the proposals at dorsetforyou.com