Reduced parking fees for lower emission vehicles in Dorset Council car parks have met with resistance.
Several councillors said the idea was unfair and unworkable – penalising those who might not be able to afford a lower emission vehicle or were unable to have an electric vehicle because they had nowhere to charge up.
The idea was thrown out by Dorset Council’s Place & Resources Overview Committee on a majority vote – but could still go forward if Cabinet overrules the committee recommendation.
Cllr Piers Brown (Con, Cranborne Chase) proposed that Dorset Council remove the idea of emission-based discounts from its car parking review as being unfair.
Cllr Simon Gibson (Verwood, Con) said he doubted if many people would see the idea as sensible at the current time.
"The longer this goes on, the more people it will annoy.
"It makes the council look as if it can’t see anything other than climate," he said.
"But for me, it doesn’t pass the sense test of who to give a discount to."
Others said it might be better to give a discount to lower-paid town centre workers who found it difficult to pay parking charges, or to offer a discount to low-income families unable to afford modern, lower emission cars – views put by Cllr Sherry Jespersen (Con, Hill Forts & Tarrants).
The committee gave support for lower resident parking fees – although how to achieve it has yet to be worked out, the council not being allowed, by law, to use automatic number plate recognition technology.
Support was also given for better car park signs – with claims that, unless you were local, it was difficult to find lower cost long-stay parking areas and, even within some council car parks, it was difficult to work out which section was short-stay and which was long-stay.
Cllr Belinda Bawden (Green, Lyme Regis & Charmouth) welcomed a report reviewing car parking policies, and in particular the idea of residents being able to have discounts.
Cllr Simon Gibson said he would welcome anything which made parking and finding a space easier which, in turn, often led to longer stays in town centres.
Cllr Piers Brown wanted to put information on parking machines to warn people paying by an app that they could get a better deal paying at the machine using cash or card.
He said the extra fee, to the app company, agreed by Dorset Council in December 2024 was unfair and had cost drivers £150,000 they need not have paid.
Charminster Cllr David Taylor (Lib Dem) also backed making parking fee payments easier but said that even in central Dorchester many could not pay by app because there was no internet signal.
Other suggestions included putting shelter-style parking bays into Dorset car parks fitted with solar panels above.
Cllr Roland Tarr (Lib Dem, Broadmayne) said in France the idea had caught on, producing car park owners extra income.
Dorset Council is looking at a shake-up of parking across the county after a review found that demand is concentrated in a small number of central and coastal car parks while other sites are often under-used.
The report put overall use of council car parks as moderate, but said pressure is high in key town-centre and seaside locations, especially during peak periods – which can lead to congestion, poorer air quality and reduced accessibility, with cars driving around unnecessarily looking for spaces while peripheral or seasonal sites had spare capacity.
The council is also considering upgrades to parking meter terminals so drivers can enter their registration number and pay for a virtual ticket, removing the need for paper tickets and allowing tariff information to be updated digitally.
The report says that maintaining the current approach or introducing uniform parking charges across Dorset were both rejected, as neither would deal with congestion, perceived unfairness or inefficiencies.
Dorset Council has said no final decisions have yet been made and that early ideas are being discussed with councillors before detailed proposals are developed for public debate.
Share