Abbotsbury key to gypsy alibi in Elizabeth Canning case

An illustration of Elizabeth Canning confronting Mary “Gipsy” Squires, whose alibi placed her in the Dorset village of Abbotsbury at the time of the alleged kidnapping <i>(Image: NQ)</i>
An illustration of Elizabeth Canning confronting Mary “Gipsy” Squires, whose alibi placed her in the Dorset village of Abbotsbury at the time of the alleged kidnapping (Image: NQ)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

THE villagers of Abbotsbury played a part in the strange tale of an 18-year-old girl called Elizabeth Canning who claimed she was kidnapped by gypsies.

Abbotsbury proved to be the unlikely link in this case, one of Georgian England’s most contested trials.

Elizabeth Canning disappeared from her home in Enfield, Middlesex for four weeks in 1753 and when she reappeared a month later she was battered, pale and thin.

She said she had been abducted, robbed and imprisoned, held in a house north of London. She accused a group of travellers of kidnapping her.

Canning named an elderly woman, Mary Squires, widely described at the time as a “gypsy”, as one of her captors. The accusation quickly escalated into a national scandal.

Gypsy Squires was arrested and put on trial. On the strength of Elizabeth's testimony, Squires was convicted and sentenced to death by hanging. Mother Wells, also named by Canning, was also found guilty and sentenced to be branded.

An illustration of Elizabeth Canning confronting Mary “Gipsy” Squires, whose alibi placed her in the Dorset village of Abbotsbury at the time of the alleged kidnapping (Image: NQ)

But the case soon began to turn, based largely on evidence from far outside London: Squires’s alibi placed her more than 130 miles away, in Abbotsbury - and witnesses agreed with her.

At the time of the alleged kidnapping, witnesses from Abbotsbury stated that Squires was staying in and around the village. Residents testified that they had seen her over a number of days in early January, lodging locally and moving about the area. The distances involved made it impossible for her to have been present at the Enfield Wash House described by Canning.

These statements became central to the defence. Sir Crisp Gascoyne, the Lord Mayor of London, took the Dorset evidence seriously and began to question inconsistencies in Canning’s account.

Multiple witnesses supported the Abbotsbury timeline, and no credible explanation emerged for how Squires could have travelled back and forth unnoticed.

Elizabeth Canning was then tried for perjury and at the trial 36 witnesses from Abbotsbury claimed to have seen the gypsy.

The focus of the courts then shifted to Canning herself. She was charged with perjury for swearing to a false account under oath. Later that year, she was convicted and sentenced to seven years’ transportation to America.

In April 1754, Mary Squires received a royal pardon.

Historians remain divided over whether she fabricated the story, was mistaken, or believed an experience that unfolded differently from how she described it.

What is clear is that the testimony of villagers in Dorset played a decisive role in stopping the execution of a woman whose guilt had been widely assumed.

The case left a lasting mark on 18th century legal history, exposing the risks of prejudice in the courts and the growing importance of corroborated evidence.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos