West Dorset home with view over Lyme Regis labelled 'bonkers'

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

PLANS for a replacement home overlooking Lyme Regis have been described as “bonkers” by local councillor Belinda Bawden.

She and town councillors had objected to the proposal to demolish and replace a home in the grounds of Farnham House, off Stile Lane – although a planning committee has now approved the plans.

A previous application for the same site had been rejected with a Planning Inspector later upholding that decision.

The main objections against the proposed property was its bulk, scale and height.

A Dorset Council planning officer had proposed accepting the latest plans saying the materials now being suggested fitted in better with Farnham House itself and the proposed property was less wide than the rejected application, although would be higher than the existing home.

Melanie Gradden, the chair of the Farnham House residents committee claimed the new proposal is even bigger in bulk and scale, especially with the balcony, than the one previously rejected.

She claimed it would cause ‘harm’ to the conservation area and Farnham House itself and came without any environmental benefits, such as heat pumps.

“It is a Poorly thought-out design, unsuitable for the site,” she said.

Applicant Denise Russell said she was puzzled how the town council raised no objection to the larger, rejected proposal, and yet were now objecting to what she described as a ‘smaller and softer’ design, with reduced window sizes and a lower roof line than nearby buildings.

“It has been a long and costly journey where we have constantly comprised,” she said, asking the councillors on the area committee to grant approval.

Lyme Regis Town Council deputy clerk Mark Green said town councillors felt very little had changed from the previous applications which had been refused.

“It appears only minimal attempts have been made to address the concerns… the scale, bulk and mass is out of keeping and unsympathetic to the surroundings,” he said.

Charmouth and Lyme Regis ward councillor Belinda Bawden said the area of town where the new home is proposed is one of the few places where the town’s historical heritage is very evident with many listed buildings.

She said the area, further down Stile Lane, had collapsed this winter and climate change remained a threat to the stability of some parts of the town, especially those near the site which had not been pinned.

“This proposal is out of scale, out of sympathy with nearby buildings… this proposal is going to be incredibly visible and out of character with the general heritage of that area,” she said.

“Above the woodlands and above the gardens the land has not been pinned, we have also had landslides the other side of Cobb Road…

“ I just feel it is bonkers, given what we know about climate change and increased rainfall and land instability, to be building a large building in that site which is going to impose on the landscape (viewed) from the gardens and on the look and feel of the buildings in that conservation area.”

Cllrs Kate Wheller and Paul Kimber told the committee that the applicant had made efforts to make their new home fit in with the area and said they would support it.

The committee voted to approve the application.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos